Is your insulation doing what you think it is doing?

I do not want to tackle the huge ugly topic of whether fiberglass insulation should be used at all–as it frequently is in attics.

For today, I just want to talk about one obvious issue with fiberglass insulation that prevents it from performing as expected.

The short version of what is wrong with fiberglass insulation is that it is not an air barrier, therefor, if it is not encapsulated and air sealed on all six sides its performance suffers. In an attic, at most, only five sides is likely to be sealed leaving the entire top not sealed.

This post is about the sides, which can and must be air sealed. The vented sides are typically not adequately air sealed, especially along the eaves. Insulation baffles, designed to keep insulation out of the lower roof venting and to allow for air flow into the attic, rarely gets adequately sealed.

Soffit vent that allows air flow into the attic

Because the baffle/top plate connection is not air sealed, and because fiberglass insulation represents very little resistance to air flow, air pushes its way into the attic right through the insulation. As it does this, it either cools the ceiling in the area, or warms the ceiling in the area depending on the season and/or side of the house.

In the winter and/or the north side of the home, the air will tend to make the ceiling cooler in the area of the vent. In the summer, especially on the sun side, the air will tend to warm the ceiling in the area of the vent. This will increase both heating and cooling loads of the home.

This next picture shows what that area looks like at the interior ceiling with Infrared camera on the South side of the home. Warm air is moving through the insulation and warming the ceiling.

In the same house on the North side we can see how the ceiling area near the vent, as indicated by infrared camera, is “cooler.” In the actual picture we can see the fungal growth present because this vent happens to be in the area of the bathroom. The moisture in the bathroom condenses on the cooler surface creating a perfect environment for mold growth.

The only real repair for this condition is to pull back the insulation and properly air seal the gaps where the insulation baffle and the house framing meet.

Spray foams are good for sealing the areas where the baffle makes contact with the framing as indicated in the circle in the picture above. Of course, in a perfect world, we would not use fiberglass insulation at all, and instead use types of insulation that are much better at stopping the flow of air. Cellulose fiber insulation can do a much better job at this.

 

Charles Buell, Real Estate Inspections in Seattle

More attic ventilation is not going to help

Many people seem to think that ventilation is the answer to all moisture issues in the attic. The reality is that adequate ventilation–proper ventilation–will only deal with “normal” moisture conditions that the attic space is subjected to (in most cases).

Another way of stating this is that the best ventilation in the world will not deal with moisture condensing out of an inordinate amount of warm moist air finding its way into the attic. A while back, I inspected a home with ideal ventilation and yet it still had one of the worst condensation issues I have seen for some time.

atticventilation1

For our discussion here, we are going to assume the roof does not leak.

At least as important as ventilation, if not more important, is having a proper air barrier between the living space and the attic/roof structure. If this air barrier is not continuous, moisture that is in the warm air that finds its way into the attic space, can, and will, condense on the cold surfaces it contacts–if that surface is cold enough. If these surfaces are below freezing then it will show up as frost.

There are an almost endless number of places that might not be properly sealed that will amount to breeches in the air barrier. Here is a partial list:

Openings around B-vents and chimneys,

Wiring holes,

Pipe penetrations,

Ventilation fans terminating in the attic,

Dryer vents terminating in the attic,

Heating ducts not sealed adequately,

Unsealed can lights,

Skylight penetrations,

Poor framing techniques,

Missing vapor barriers in some climates,

Attic access covers with no weather-stripping,

Ventilation fan housings,

And, Electrical junction boxes.

Obviously many of these cannot be determined in the course of a standard home inspection because of access and/or insulation. Repairs can be easy or difficult depending on how obvious the by-passes are.

In the case of this house there were a few obvious things that should be addressed prior to removal of all the insulation.

From the roof, thanks to the frost, one can see where there is less frost in one area and no snow in a large area that corresponds to the shape of the chimney chase at the interior of the home.

atticventilation2

It does not take a rocket scientist to guess that the connection of the chase with the attic is not adequately sealed.

There were also exhaust vents terminating in the attic and there was no weather-stripping on the access cover. Addressing these three issues would be the first order of business. If that does not fix the issue then, the investigation would need to become more “aggressive.”

But that is not the whole story with this house. Another question that had to be asked and answered was why were moisture levels within the home so high? This was evidenced by condensation on windows that didn’t have any curtains or blinds. (Even under normal humidity levels in the home–when it is really cold outside–some amount of condensation will occur on windows that have curtains or blinds that limit air circulation.)

Of course lifestyle can be a factor. If the occupants don’t use exhaust fans when showering or the fans are not functional we can expect to have higher humidity inside the home–which can then find its way into the roof structure. But there was another big hint as to another possible source of moisture to the indoor environment–the crawl space. At many locations around the home there was evidence of poor air sealing at wall floor connections consistent with air infiltrating/exfiltrating from the crawl space. It was particularly evident at the steps from the entryway up to the main floor level as can be seen with the “ghosting” in the following picture.

atticventilation3

A LOT of air is coming and going at these black areas and the carpet is a pretty good filter.

If the crawl space is “cold” and at high humidity and that air is drawn indoors where it is then warmed by air at high humidity the indoor air becomes even more humid. Stack effect works to continually pull air from the crawl space through the living space and on into the attic space.  The crawl space was flooded in some areas and showed a history of being flooded–worse than when I was there.

atticventilation4

So now we have an attic moisture issue that is only likely to be fixed when the house drainage system is fixed–along with all the other by-pass issues we discussed.

Some people think that if they add a POWER vent they will surely move enough air out of the attic. But really this only serves to put the attic under even greater negative pressure thereby increasing the draw of moist warm air from the home.

More attic ventilation is not going to help.

By Charles Buell, Real Estate Inspections in Seattle

If you enjoyed this post, and would like to get notices of new posts to my blog, please subscribe via email in the little box to the right. I promise NO spamming of your email! 🙂

Venting attics

I have blogged about this particular issue in the past.  This defect is not common in New Construction.  It usually occurs in homes that have been re-roofed.  I am talking about compromised attic venting due to “opposing” systems being installed.

Older gable roofed homes typically had gable vents.  Historically, as we came to understand how venting works, and came to understand the problems associated with inadequately vented attics and roof structures, we moved away from the use of gable vents.  Gable venting relies on movement through the vents from one end of the attic to the other to change the air in the attic—and hopefully to carry any moisture that has entered the attic with it.  While in some cases this can be adequate, it often left areas of the attic “under-ventilated” due to poor circulation.  This system was also subject to poor venting depending on the house’s orientation to the prevailing wind direction.

The next approach was to have soffit vents that circulated air up to roof vents located near the ridge of the roof.  This was better but could still be affected by wind direction and in some cases the vents could be buried in snow drifting across the ridge.

By far the best method of venting the attic space is to have soffit vents that work in conjunction with continuous type ridge vents.  As wind moves across the ridge from any direction it acts to pull air out of the attic. I discussed this principle previously in, Ridge Vents–venting of roofs and attics.

So how does improper venting happen in New Construction?

It is easier to see how it happens in old.  For example:  the gable vents are already there—-and no one thinks to cover them up.  The roof vents are already there—-and it is easier to put another roof vent over the hole than it is to patch the hole and then properly patch the roof.  Perhaps the framers were just used to cutting the holes but the roofers where trying to do better?  Lack of communication perhaps?  Whatever the reasons, it shows a serious flaw in someone’s understanding of basic building science.  The following picture, from inside the attic, shows how the air is likely to flow to the continuous-type roof vent—-pulling little air from the soffit vents.

 

Improper attic venting

Improper attic venting

Charles Buell, Seattle Home Inspector

If you enjoyed this post, and would like to get notices of new posts to my blog, please subscribe via email in the little box to the right. I promise NO spamming of your email :-D